419-342-4131
Our Family Protecting the Future of Yours

Your Shelby Mutual Insurance Agents

Tammy Armintrout

Tammy has been a pillar in the Shelby Mutual Insurance agency since 1993! Starting as a part time employee she became a partner in 2005 and currently serves as the President of the Agency! Prior to the agency, Tammy worked for Shelby Mutual Insurance Company extending her Insurance experience over 30 Years! Born and Raised in Shelby, she enjoys spending time with family and watching the Cavs and Indians. Tammy lives in Shelby with her husband Todd and has 2 Children, Justin and Jessica and is the Grandmother to Triplets!

Contact Tammy by E-Mail at tammy@shelbyagency.com

Justin Armintrout

Justin Armintrout, licensed in Property & Casualty and Life & Health and is a 2nd generation agent in the office. Managing the daily office operations, Justin is also able to serve our client’s needs with Auto, Home, Life, & Business Insurance programs.

A graduate of Shelby High School, Justin went on to earn his Bachelors and Master’s Degrees from the University of Findlay and spent several years as a collegiate strength and conditioning coach, including winning a Big Ten Championship prior to his start in Insurance. Justin is a member of the Shelby Rotary Club and is involved with the Richland Young Professionals. Justin lives in Shelby with his Wife Nicole and their Triplets Harper, Parker & Carter.

Contact Justin by E-Mail at justin@shelbyagency.com

Tyler Korbas

The Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency welcomes a new agent to their team. Tyler Korbas is licensed in Property & Casualty and Life & Health comes into the agency with over 2 years prior experience in the insurance industry. Tyler will be serving the needs of customers on all fronts, Auto, Home, Life, and Commercial Insurance.

A graduate of Shelby High School, Tyler has resided in Columbus, Ohio for the last three years before recently moving back to Shelby. Tyler enjoys spending his free time with his daughter, Emerson, and playing golf at The Shelby Country Club.

Contact Tyler by E-Mail at tyler@shelbyagency.com

Shelby Ohio Insurance Shelby Ohio Insurance