419-342-4131
Our Family Protecting the Future of Yours


About Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency

The Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency has provided insurance services to Shelby and the surrounding area since 1919.

Certified Snapshot Agency

The Agency, located at 55 W Main Street in Shelby, is a multi-generation family owned and managed business by Tammy Armintrout and Justin Armintrout with nearly 40 years combined insurance experience. The office expanded this year with the addition of its newest agent, Tyler Korbas. In its 98th year in business, SMIA continues to strive to provide unmatched customer service while protecting the things you work hard for.

At the Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency all of your insurance needs can be met with a complete line of Personal and Commercial Insurance products. Auto, Homeowners, Life, Business Insurance and Bonds are available as well as insurance for your motorcycle and ATV.

Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency represents Erie Insurance Group, Progressive Insurance, Celina Insurance and several other reputable insurance companies.

Contact us and let our knowledgeable staff help make sure you and your family are properly covered! Our motto is "Our Family Protecting the Future of Yours!"


Shelby Ohio Insurance Shelby Ohio Insurance